Hey, everyone! I’m Ben – the Amateur Exegete, and this is episode eighty-four of Bible Study for Amateurs. Today’s episode is, “Jonah 1:7-10.”1
We are continuing our series on the book of Jonah, using the tools from our Amateur Toolbox.2 (As a reminder, if you’re interested in digging deeper, the script for each episode can be found at my website – amateurexegete.com – and include endnotes that offer citations and further discussion.) In the last episode, we looked at Jonah 1:4-6, a section wherein Yahweh hurls a storm upon the sea that motivates fear in the sailors but elicits no reaction but deep slumber in Jonah. In this episode, we will look at the sailors’ interrogation of the prophet and what they discover.
Whence This Trouble?
Here is Jonah 1:7-10 as it appears in the NRSVue:3
7 The sailors said to one another, “Come, let us cast lots, so that we may know on whose account this calamity has come upon us.” So they cast lots, and the lot fell on Jonah. 8 Then they said to him, “Tell us why this calamity has come upon us. What is your occupation? Where do you come from? What is your country? And of what people are you?” 9 “I am a Hebrew,” he replied. “I worship the LORD, the God of heaven, who made the sea and the dry land.” 10 Then the men were even more afraid and said to him, “What is this that you have done?” For the men knew that he was fleeing from the presence of the LORD, because he had told them so.
In vv. 4-6, as the storm rages no one on the vessel suspects that Jonah is the cause of their dire straits. In fact, the sailors recruited him to pray to his god just as they had prayed to their own. In v. 7, we discover that prayers aren’t working and so the sailors turn to an ancient method of figuring out the divine will: casting lots.
“The lot is cast into the lap,” says the author of Proverbs 16:33, “but the decision is the LORD’s alone.” In his notes on the verse for The Jewish Study Bible, Michael Fox writes, “The casting of lots was a wide-spread method of divination in the ancient world. In one form, names, or ‘yes’ and ‘no,’ would be written on stones, which were shaken till one fell out. This was thought to indicate what God wanted.”4 This seems to me to be little more than an ancient version of the Magic 8-Ball that used to be popular decades ago. For ancient peoples, including the author of the book of Jonah, cleromancy was a tried-and-true method of figuring out the divine will. And in this case, it works perfectly: “the lot fell on Jonah” we read at the end of v. 7.
The sailors begin to interrogate the sleeper, peppering him with question after question to figure out why the lot fell on him.5 They ask about his occupation,6 his place of origin, his home country, and his ethnicity. Jonah responds only to the last question: “I am a Hebrew…. I worship the LORD, the God of heaven,7 who made the sea and the dry land.” There is a measure of contradiction and irony here in Jonah’s response, or, in the words of Kelly Murphy in the Women’s Bible Commentary, the prophet’s response is both “comical” and “inappropriate.”8
First, his claim to “worship the LORD” stands in complete opposite of his actions so far in the story. Can he really claim to worship Yahweh when, so far, he has done nothing but try to avoid doing what the deity has commanded him? Adam and Eve were expelled from the garden because they ate the wrong fruit (see Gen 3:22-24). Moses was denied entry into the Promised Land because he struck a rock to draw out water rather than merely speak to it as Yahweh had commanded (see Num 20:1-13). This is a deity who wants to get his way and will go to great lengths to either get it or punish those who deny it. But Jonah thought both that he was a worshipper of Yahweh and that he could refuse his god’s commands?
Second, the prophet recognizes that Yahweh is the deity who “made the sea and the dry land.” And yet here he is on a vessel bound for Tarshish in the middle of the sea while a tempest rages around him because he figured that by hopping on board he could flee from Yahweh’s presence. John Kaltner writes in his note on v. 9 for The SBL Study Bible, “Jonah’s pious confession of faith in God as creator of the sea and the dry land underscores the futility of his attempt to escape from God’s presence.”9 It is noteworthy that the prophet doesn’t ascribe to Yahweh creation of “the dry land and the sea.” He begins with the sea, perhaps, as Ehud Ben Zvi notes in The Jewish Study Bible, because of where they are at that moment, far from “the dry land.”10
To the prophet’s words, v. 10 reports, the response of the sailors is more fear and the inquiry, “What is this that you have done?” They are no doubt shocked.11 Who in their right mind refuses the call of their god? Gods were beings with which one did not trifle.12 They were not only powerful, but they were often petty, a combination that could spell disaster for the reluctant worshipper. Yahweh was no different, proclaiming in Exod 34:14 that his “name is Jealous.” The sailors, being pagans, likely knew very little about Jonah’s god but their response reflects the anxieties of ancient worshippers, and thus their fear reveals a piety that Jonah does not apparently possess.13 For them it is not theoretical: with their own eyes they can see the storm around them, and beneath their feet the ship is threatening to break apart, drowning everyone on board. Jonah had been sleeping until the captain woke him up!
The sailors’ reaction plays into one of the larger themes of the book of Jonah, namely that pagans can be pious too. Jonah is a mere pretender; he can say whatever he wishes but, as the old adage goes, the proof of the pudding is in the eating. These pagan sailors, on the other hand, pray to their own gods (Jon 1:5) but nevertheless recognize that anyone who thinks they can just escape their deity is probably a fool. “For the men knew that [Jonah] was fleeing from the presence of the LORD, because he had told them so,” we read at the end of v. 10.14
But what to do about the situation? They’ve already tried hurling the ship’s cargo overboard and prayer obviously didn’t do the trick. What moves do they have left to avoid being swept away by the waves of the sea?
That’s it for this episode of Bible Study for Amateurs. I’ll see you next time! If you’d like to support this podcast, share it on social media, subscribe to it on the listening platform of your choice, or head over to amateurexegete.com and click on the support button. Or do all three! And, most importantly, remember, in the words of Richard Elliot Friedman, “One does not need to deny what is troubling [about the Bible] in order to pay respect to what is heartening.”15
- Throughout the endnotes readers will find various abbreviations. For a list of what abbreviations I use and the works to which they refer, please see the page “Commonly Used Abbreviations.” ↩︎
- You can find the episodes on that toolbox here. ↩︎
- Unless otherwise noted, all quotations of biblical texts are from the New Revised Standard Version Updated Edition. ↩︎
- Michael V. Fox, “Proverbs,” in The Jewish Study Bible, edited by Adele Berlin and Marc Zvi Brettler, second edition (Oxford University Press, 2014), 1463. ↩︎
- Jione Havea (Jonah: An Earth Bible Commentary [T&T Clark, 2020], 25-26) observes that by these questions the men are trying to figure out just what kind of person Jonah is. Is he evil? Is he good? ↩︎
- Or “mission.” See W. Dennis Tucker Jr., Jonah: A Handbook on the Hebrew Text (Baylor University Press, 2006), 30; Jack M. Sasson, Jonah: A New Translation with Introduction, Commentary, and Interpretations, AYB 24B (Doubleday, 1990), 113-114. ↩︎
- On the epithet “god of heaven,” see Susan Niditch, Jonah: A Commentary, Hermeneia (Fortress Press, 2023), 46-47; Jack M. Sasson, Jonah: A New Translation with Introduction, Commentary, and Interpretations, AYB 24B (Doubleday, 1990), 118. ↩︎
- Kelly J. Murphy, “Jonah,” in Women’s Bible Commentary, edited by Carol A. Newsom, Sharon H. Ringe, and Jacqueline E. Lapsley, third edition (Westminster John Knox Press, 2012), 322. ↩︎
- John Kalnter, “Jonah,” in The SBL Study Bible, edited by Steven L. McKenzie, Kristin De Troyer, and F. Scott Spencer (HarperCollins Publishers, 2023), 1260. ↩︎
- Ehud Ben Zvi, “Jonah,” in The Jewish Study Bible, edited by Adele Berlin and Marc Zvi Brettler, second edition (Oxford University Press, 2014), 1189. On the possibility that the term “the dry land” is a nod to creation and the Exodus, see Sasson, Jonah, 119. ↩︎
- See Sasson, Jonah, 120. ↩︎
- Douglas Stuart, Hosea-Jonah, WBC 31 (Word, Inc.,), 465. ↩︎
- Havea (Jonah, 26) writes that “the fear of the men was more intense than Jonah’s.” ↩︎
- Niditch (Jonah, 48) refers to this as “Homer’s nodding” wherein a storyteller omits a detail and then later fills it in to fill the void, as it were. ↩︎
- Richard Elliot Friedman, The Exodus: How It Happened and Why It Matters (HarperOne, 2017), 214. ↩︎